November 4th week - Can a Multinational Company Dismiss an Executive with 27 Years of Service Simply on Headquarters’ Orders?
Can a Multinational
Company Dismiss an Executive with 27 Years of Service Simply on Headquarters’
Orders?
Bongsoo
Jung, Labor Attorney / Kangnam Labor Law Firm
“Swiss headquarters has decided that you must be
dismissed. The Korean branch has no choice but to follow its instructions.”
An executive who had devoted 27 years to
one company suddenly received a notice of dismissal. The employer was a
multinational corporation that placed great emphasis on anti-corruption and
business ethics. The allegation was that he had been involved in improper
dealings with a business partner while previously working at headquarters. Yet
the Korean branch had neither adequately investigated what he had actually done
nor given him an opportunity to explain. Could a decision made by global
headquarters automatically constitute a valid dismissal in Korea?
1. A Dismissal Notice at
the End of a 27-Year Career
Company B was the Korean branch of a
multinational corporation headquartered in Switzerland. After a total of 27
years of service at headquarters and the Korean branch, the employee was
appointed an executive director of the Korean branch on December 1, 2025, and
entered into a two-year employment contract. While adjusting well to his new
position and carrying out his duties, he unexpectedly received notice of
dismissal on June
30, 2026.
The dispute arose from allegations of
improper transactions in the sales department of the Swiss headquarters in 2025.
The company had dismissed the sales executives involved and considered this
employee, who had been responsible for technical work at the time, to have been
implicated as well. The employee offered a different account. He maintained
that he had not been responsible for the transactions or pricing decisions and
had merely been copied (CC’d) on an email sent by someone implicated in the
allegations.
The most important issue was not simply
whether suspicions existed. The Korean branch immediately dismissed the
employee in accordance with headquarters’ decision without independently
verifying his actual involvement. The central question was whether the Korean
employer itself could substantiate both the evidence supporting the dismissal
and the procedures followed.
2. Can Headquarters’
Global Code of Conduct Replace Korean Dismissal Standards?
The company’s position was unequivocal. It
had a global code of conduct strictly prohibiting the disclosure of
confidential information, improper transactions, and bribery, as well as the
failure to report such conduct when known. Employees had been made familiar
with the code and had signed acknowledgments of compliance. The company also
cited a provision of its rules of employment concerning disqualification from
appointment, arguing that it would not have appointed the employee to the
Korean branch had it known of the serious misconduct allegedly committed during
his previous assignment.
The importance of business ethics and
compliance cannot be denied. However, the existence of a code of conduct does
not replace proof of which particular obligation an individual employee
actually violated. Moreover, the argument that “we would not have hired him had
we known” must be distinguished from cases involving actual falsification of
employment history or concealment of material facts at the time of hiring. It
is a separate matter for the Korean branch to treat an unverified allegation
from headquarters as an immediate ground for dismissal.
Article 23 of the Korean Labor Standards
Act prohibits dismissal without justifiable cause. The legitimacy of a
disciplinary dismissal must be assessed comprehensively in light of the
misconduct established, the employee’s position and duties, the degree of
responsibility, and the impact on the employment relationship. A strict policy
at overseas headquarters does not automatically make a dismissal lawful in
Korea.
3. Dismissal Is the Most
Severe Disciplinary Measure: Grounds and Proportionality
The employee emphasized that he had not
been responsible for the transactions and had merely been copied on an email.
Receiving an email is not the same as knowingly participating in, or
acquiescing in, an improper transaction. This was why the company needed to
establish the misconduct and each individual’s responsibility with specificity.
Company B’s rules of employment provided
for several disciplinary measures besides dismissal, including removal from
position, demotion, suspension, reduction in pay, and reprimand. Even where
grounds for discipline exist, a dismissal may be unjustified if it is
disproportionately severe in relation to the misconduct. The employee’s 27
years of service, assigned duties, extent of involvement, and previous work
record were all relevant considerations. The appropriateness of immediately
imposing the most severe sanction was therefore also in question.
4. No Disciplinary
Committee and No Opportunity to Respond
A clearer problem in this case concerned
procedure. Company B’s rules of employment required a disciplinary committee to
be established before a disciplinary decision was made. The committee had to
consist of at least three members appointed by the chief executive officer. The
rules also required written notice to the employee at least seven days before
the committee meeting, together with an opportunity to present a defense.
Nevertheless, the Korean branch convened
no disciplinary committee and gave the employee no opportunity to explain. In
carrying out headquarters’ instruction, it bypassed the procedures prescribed
in its own rules of employment. This was a significant procedural defect that
could undermine the validity of the dismissal independently of the company’s
substantive allegations.
Even today, where rules of employment or a
collective bargaining agreement prescribe mandatory disciplinary procedures, a
failure to observe them generally calls the legitimacy of the disciplinary
action into question. However, not every procedural violation necessarily
produces the same legal result; the nature of the requirement and any
exceptional circumstances must be examined. Article 27 of the current Labor
Standards Act separately requires written notice specifying the grounds for
dismissal and the effective date of dismissal.
5. The Decisive Questions
at the Labor Relations Commission
The employee filed an application for
remedy against unfair dismissal. At the hearing before the Labor Relations
Commission on September 17, 2026, the company was unable to provide specific
evidence explaining how the employee had actually participated in the improper
transactions. It also failed to offer an adequate explanation for not following
the disciplinary procedures set out in its rules of employment.
During the hearing, the commission chair
proposed a settlement. The choice was not easy for the employee. Returning to
the company to which he had devoted 27 years was important, but approximately
11 months remained on his two-year contract with the Korean branch, and there
was no guarantee that he would be able to return to the Swiss headquarters when
that contract expired.
Ultimately, the employee chose a practical
resolution. He received a settlement payment equivalent to nine months of his
annual salary and withdrew his unfair dismissal application. This case
therefore did not end with a final ruling by the Labor Relations Commission
that the dismissal was unfair. Rather, the parties reached a settlement after
the legal risks became apparent during the hearing. It is important to
distinguish the settlement outcome from a formal legal determination.
6. Lessons for
Multinational Companies in 2026
Today, Korean entities of global companies
increasingly encounter headquarters-led ethics investigations, whistleblower
reports, data audits, and recommendations for personnel action. However, a
multinational organization must comply both with its consistent global
standards and with the mandatory provisions of the Korean Labor Standards Act.
The fact that headquarters conducted an investigation does not relieve the
Korean employer of its responsibility to verify the relevant facts.
First, the Korean employer should review
the headquarters’ investigation materials and identify the facts and evidence
applicable to the employee in Korea. Second, it should distinguish conduct
personally undertaken by the employee from information that the employee merely
received or on which the employee was copied. Third, it should assess the
proportionality of the proposed disciplinary sanction and consistency with
precedents involving other employees. Fourth, it must follow the disciplinary
committee, advance notice, and opportunity-to-be-heard procedures required by
the Korean rules of employment and employment contract. Fifth, if dismissal is
ultimately decided upon, the employer must provide written notice specifying
the grounds and effective date. It should also be remembered that an
application for remedy against unfair dismissal must, in principle, be filed
within three months of the dismissal.
These steps are not formalities designed
to shield wrongdoing. Where the evidence is sufficient, they enable the
employer to impose an appropriate sanction lawfully. Where the evidence is
inadequate, they reduce the losses that a hasty decision can inflict on both
the company and the employee.
7. Before Following
Headquarters’ Orders, Check the Law and the Facts
This case began with a single instruction
from headquarters. But its outcome turned on two questions the Korean branch
could not answer: “What exactly did this employee do wrong?” and “Did the
company follow the required procedures before dismissing him?”
Global standards are necessary to raise
corporate ethical standards. Yet dismissing an employee in Korea must withstand
scrutiny under Korean law. An organization that examines headquarters’
instructions against the facts and applicable procedures, and then makes an
accountable decision, is stronger than one that merely executes those
instructions quickly. That is why this longstanding dispute involving an
executive with 27 years of service remains relevant today.
| No | Title | Date | Access | File |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| November 4th week - Can a Multinational Company Dismiss an Executive with 27 Years of Service Simply on Headquarters’ Orders? N | 26.11.22 | 39 | ||
| 291 | November 3rd week - Is Voluntary Retirement Really a Voluntary Choice? | 26.11.15 | 258 | |
| 290 | November 2nd week - From Recruitment to Retirement: Assessing Age Discrimination and Available Remedies | 26.11.08 | 408 | |
| 289 | October 4th week - The Unpaid Wages Case Involving 339 Election Campaign Workers | 26.10.25 | 1258 | |
| 288 | October 3rd week - Is Paying a Higher Salary Enough? Understanding Korea’s Minimum Wage Law in 2026 | 26.10.20 | 1592 | |
| 287 | October 2nd week - A Foreign Teacher’s Fight Against Unfair Dismissal | 26.10.10 | 1535 | |
| 286 | October 1st week - Limitations and Exceptions to the Employment Period of Fixed-Term Employees | 26.10.04 | 1706 | |
| 285 | September 5th week - Dismissal by a Foreign Parent Company and the Application of Korean Labor Law | 26.09.27 | 1730 | |
| 284 | September 4th week - Freelancer or Employee? Substance Matters More Than the Contract | 26.09.20 | 1262 | |
| 283 | September 3rd week - Cases Concerning the Validity of Disciplinary Procedures | 26.09.13 | 1153 | |
| 282 | September 2nd week - Same Steel Mill, Different Conclusions: Criteria for Distinguishing In-House Subcontracting from Illegal Worker Dispatch | 26.09.06 | 1399 | |
| 281 | September 1st week - Scope of Duties and Areas of Practice for Labor Attorneys (As of August 2026) | 26.08.30 | 1650 | |
| 280 | August 4th week - Lockout: Requirements for a Lawful Lockout and Its Legal Effects | 26.08.22 | 1667 | |
| 279 | August 3rd week - Criteria for Determining Ordinary Wages and Calculating Additional Pay - Changes and Practical Issues Following the 2024 Supreme Court En Banc Decisions- | 26.08.16 | 65108 | |
| 278 | August 2nd week - Retirement Pension System (Revised Version Based on Laws and Regulations as of August 2026) | 26.08.09 | 2371 | |
| 277 | August 1st week - Contractual Leave: Types and HR Considerations | 26.08.02 | 1906 | |
| 276 | July 4th week - Occupational Lung Disease Recognized through an Epidemiological Investigation | 26.07.26 | 1870 | |
| 275 | July 3rd week - A Restructuring Case: From a Redundancy Plan to a Voluntary Retirement | 26.07.18 | 2480 | |
| 274 | July 2nd week - Justification for Dismissal Due to Poor Sales Performance | 26.07.12 | 2907 | |
| 273 | July 1st week - A Case Study on Collective Bargaining by a University Cleaning Workers’ Union and Its Practical Implications for Labor-Management Relations in 2026 | 26.07.05 | 2193 |

